"Mr. Ambassador, as time goes on we know that the odds of my son and the other relatives on the plane having survived becomes
smaller and smaller," said a grey-haired man named Wen.
As he addressed the
Malaysian diplomat seated at a table just a few feet away in the packed
Beijing hotel conference room, Wen began sobbing uncontrollably into a
microphone. It had been more than 45 days since his son disappeared
aboard missing Malaysian Airlines flight MH370.
"To know that somebody is
alive, you need to see them. To know that somebody is dead, you need to
see the body. That's all I ask of you," Wen concluded, weeping. Members
of the audience sobbed quietly in their seats.
Visibly uncomfortable,
the representative from Malaysia's embassy in Beijing, could do little
more than repeat his government's talking points. "There's a team coming
to answer your questions. Let them come. Let them come," he pleaded.
But the words from deputy
chief of mission Bala Chandran Tharman only angered the relatives. They
erupted into fist-waving chants: "Live up to commitments! No more
delays! No more lies!"
Each day seems to bring
another disappointment to the hundreds of Chinese relatives waiting for
news about missing loved ones. 153 Chinese nationals flew aboard the
ill-fated flight. For more than a month, Malaysian Airlines has housed
hundreds of their relatives in a number of Beijing hotels.
From their improvised
headquarters in Beijing's Lido Hotel, the families have set up
committees, published press releases, printed T-shirts and hats with the
slogan "Pray for MH370," while also coordinating information with the
next of kin of passengers from other countries.
This agonizing limbo has
been punctuated by highly emotional and contentious daily briefings held
with Malaysian officials in a windowless conference room in the Lido
Hotel.
Last week, relatives
stormed out of the hall en masse after technical glitches left a panel
of Malaysian technical experts mute on a giant screen. The long-awaited
video conference with Kuala Lumpur was a complete failure.
"You're all bloody liars, and you're lying to us again now!" one representative yelled, as relatives marched out of the room.
A committee representing
passengers' families in Beijing has continued pressing its case,
demanding answers to highly technical questions that were translated and
submitted in writing to the Malaysian government. To better understand
the final moments before Flight MH370 was believed to have crashed into
the Indian Ocean, they wanted the audio recording of the crew's last
radio communications with air traffic controllers, an explanation of how
many emergency locator transmitters [ELT's] the plane was carrying and
whether or not the ELT's activated as intended at the moment the
aircraft hit the ocean.
"You need to do it
yourself," explained a young Chinese physicist on the families'
technical committee, who had helped draw up the questions. The man asked
not to be identified, because he was keeping his father's disappearance
a secret for fear of upsetting his elderly grandmother.
For several days after
the failed video conference, Malaysian diplomats did not appear at daily
briefings. Instead a representative of Malaysian airlines addressed
increasingly hostile family members. Last Friday, he pledged that a
high-level team of technical experts would come to Beijing the following
Monday to brief the family members.
But that Monday, Malaysia informed family members there had been a last-minute change of plan.
"The authorities in
Malaysia would like to move forward in the endeavor to address the
missing flight MH370," said Tharman, the Malaysian deputy chief of
mission.
"While keeping in mind
that the family have many questions regarding technical issues, the
authorities over the weekend put the view that these important questions
should be taken up a little later at an appropriate time and place."
The message was not well
received. For nearly three hours, Chinese relatives took turns yelling,
begging and cursing at the Malaysian.
"Are you hiding things
from us? Are there things you are not willing to tell us?" said Jack
Song, a spokesman for the families whose wife was a passenger.
In these highly
emotional confrontations, it is clear that many of the Chinese next of
kin believe their missing loved ones are still alive.
"We have not given up hope. We dare to hope. We dare to believe," said Mr. Wen during his tearful speech on Monday.
However, hope has become
a dangerous emotion, according to a psychologist who has helped treat
some of the next of kin. "That's a dangerous thing when you artificially
manifest hope which in the end cannot be sustained. You are setting
them up for a fall," said Paul Yin, a counselling psychologist who also
treated victims of Asiana Airlines flight 214, which crashed in
California in 2013 killing at least three people.
But Yin said Malaysian
authorities bore some responsibility for the crisis. "So many of the
moves that they have taken are just so wrong," Yin said.
Malaysian officials sent to brief Chinese families are armed with little to no information on the search for the plane.
Meanwhile, in the eyes
of many passengers' relatives, contradictory statements from Kuala
Lumpur have shaken the credibility of Malaysian officials charged with
leading the investigation. Lack of information has led many to suspect a
cover-up, an accusation Malaysian authorities have repeatedly denied.
While repeatedly
challenging the Malaysian government, the passengers' families face
clear limits that appear to have been set by the Chinese authorities.
On Friday, the family
committee announced plans to hold a prayer ceremony for missing spouses
in a park near the Lido Hotel. Instead, the service was held in the same
conference room. Dozens of men and women sat cross-legged on the floor,
weeping in front of a banner that said: "Honey, it's not home without
you."
After the ceremony, the
spouses -- many dressed in "Pray for MH370" T-shirts and baseball hats,
marched out of the hotel to the park. They were closely followed by
uniformed and plain-clothed Chinese police. After a short speech in
front of the park gates, they drifted back to their hotel.
"It's just like big
cage," said Steven Wang, when asked about the hotel. The 26 year old has
become one of the main international spokespeople for the committee of
family members.
"It is full of bad emotion ... we feel sad and angry and exhausted," Wang added.
Source:CNN
No comments:
Post a Comment